Why Is Cold Calling For Insurance Sales Hard?

Cold calling is a sales technique that involves contacting potential customers by phone and pitching your policy or service without a prior relationship or referral to a potential customer. As a result, cold calling can be challenging and time-consuming.

Why Is Cold Calling for Insurance Sales Hard?

As a licensed insurance agent, I have used cold calling to contact potential customers. Throughout my professional career, I have found this can be a challenging and time-consuming task for many reasons. In this article, we will explore the challenges of using cold calling to make sales, offer tips for success, and offer alternatives to cold calling to help you use cold calling effectively. Let’s get started!

The Challenges Of Cold Calling For Insurance Sales

As an insurance broker, I have used cold calling to pitch insurance policies and services. In my professional experience, while this can be effective, it is not necessarily an easy sales method.

As an insurance salesperson, you may have experienced the dread that comes with picking up the phone and dialing a complete stranger. It’s not always easy, but it’s a necessary part of the job.

There are several challenges that insurance sales representatives may face when cold calling for sales:

  1. Lack Of Interest: Many potential customers may not be interested in purchasing insurance or may already have a policy in place. This can make it difficult to engage the potential customer and close a sale.
  1. Rejection: Cold calling can be emotionally challenging, as sales representatives may face frequent rejection from potential customers. This can be demoralizing and can lead to burnout if not properly managed.
  1. Time Management: Cold calling can be time-consuming, as sales representatives may have to make many calls to reach potential customers. It’s important to manage time effectively and prioritize calls to maximize productivity.
  1. Lack Of Information: Without a prior relationship or referral, sales representatives may have limited information about the potential customer. This can make it difficult to tailor the sales pitch and provide value to the potential customer.
  1. Legal Compliance: It’s important for insurance sales representatives to adhere to state and federal laws when cold calling, including the Do Not Call Registry and telemarketing laws. Failure to do so can result in legal consequences and damage to the company’s reputation.

Cold calling is challenging because it involves contacting potential customers who are not expecting the call, leading to a low success rate. Many people have a negative perception of unsolicited calls, which can make them unreceptive to the conversation and it requires excellent communication and persuasion skills to quickly build rapport and interest with the prospect, which can be difficult for some salespeople.

Jesse Cunningham
Work with Us to Increase Insurance Sales

Let’s Talk

Are you an insurance agent who wants to build a sales pipeline that never runs dry? Look no further. Contact us and discover how we can help you take your sales to the next level!

Tips For Successfully Cold Calling For Insurance Sales

Even though cold calling can be difficult, I have found in my professional opinion that it can still be a worthwhile sales method to consider. Despite the challenges, cold calling can be a successful tool for insurance sales if approached in the right way. Here are some tips I’ve learned throughout my career that can help you succeed using cold calling: 

  1. Research The Potential Customer: The more information you have about the potential customer, the better prepared you’ll be to tailor your sales pitch and address their needs and concerns. Look for information online, such as social media profiles or company websites, to gather insights about the potential customer.
  1. Prepare A Script: A well-prepared script can help you stay on track and effectively communicate the value of your product or service. Make sure to include an introduction, a value proposition, and a call to action.
  1. Practice Your Delivery: Cold calling can be intimidating, so it’s important to practice your delivery beforehand to feel more confident and natural on the phone.
  1. Be Persistent But Respectful: While it’s important to be persistent when cold calling, it’s also important to respect the potential customer’s time and boundaries. If they’re not interested, politely thank them for their time and move on to the next call.
  1. Follow Up: If the potential customer is interested but not ready to make a decision, follow up with them at a later date. This can help keep your product or service top of mind and increase the chances of closing a sale.

Alternatives To Cold Calling For Insurance Sales

Even though I have used cold calling with great success in my career as an insurance broker, it is not the only method to generate leads and make sales. 

Here are some alternatives I recommend based on my experience in the field:

  1. Referrals: Asking current customers for referrals is a great way to generate leads and build trust with potential customers.
  1. Social Media: Social media platforms, such as LinkedIn, can be a powerful tool for networking and generating leads.
  1. Content Marketing: Creating valuable content, such as blog posts or videos, and sharing it on your website or social media can help attract potential customers and demonstrate your expertise in the insurance industry.
  1. Email Marketing: Sending targeted email campaigns to potential customers can be an effective way to generate leads and build relationships.
  1. In-Person Networking: Attending industry events, joining local business groups, and networking in person can help generate leads and build relationships with potential customers.

By incorporating a mix of lead generation strategies, insurance sales representatives can effectively grow their business without relying solely on cold calling.


Cold calling can be a challenging but successful method of generating leads and making sales. As a licensed insurance representative, I understand the many challenges that come with the sales method, and that it may not be the best option for everyone. There are multiple alternatives to cold calling that may work better for you, but it is important to understand how to overcome the challenges of cold calling so you can use the method effectively before deciding which method works best for you. 

If you liked this blog check out our other insurance articles on: