Best Practices For Improving Open And Click-Through Rates

Email marketing can be a powerful tool for promoting services and engaging with potential and current clients for insurance agencies. However, people get emails all the time, and it’s important that your emails stand out. Doing so helps achieve high open and click-through rates.

Insurance Agency Email Marketing: Best Practices for Improving Open and Click-Through Rates

As an independent insurance agent, I know that emails are a common marketing technique for insurance agencies. However, people receive dozens of emails a day–you need to make yours stand out! In this article, we will discuss the importance of email marketing and the factors that affect its success, as well as offer tips and best practices you can implement to improve your open and click-through rates. 

The Importance Of Email Marketing For Insurance Agencies

As a licensed insurance professional, I know that email marketing is used by insurance companies frequently to market their products and services. But, what makes email marketing so important to insurance agencies? Email marketing is a cost-effective and efficient way for insurance agencies to reach out to potential and current clients. 

It allows you to target specific segments of your audience and personalize your messaging, which can help increase the effectiveness of your campaigns.

Email marketing can be used for a variety of purposes such as promoting new insurance products and services, announcing special offers or discounts, and providing helpful information or resources to your audience. 

It can also be an effective way to stay top of mind with clients and nurture leads over time. In addition to its promotional benefits, email marketing can also help you build relationships with your audience and increase customer loyalty. 

One of the best things I’ve done to stay in front of my clients with emails is producing different YouTube videos and then using a service like MailChimp to periodically send them. This is an easy and effective way to remind your clients of your services while maintaining a relationship to them because they get to see your face and hear your voice.

Work with Us to Increase Insurance Sales

Let’s Talk

Are you an insurance agent who wants to build a sales pipeline that never runs dry? Look no further. Contact us and discover how we can help you take your sales to the next level!

Factors That Affect Open And Click-Through Rates

In my opinion as an insurance professional, before you can improve your open and click-through rates, you needs to understand what affects them. There are several factors that can affect the open and click-through rates of your insurance agency’s email marketing campaigns. Some of these include:

  1. The Subject Line: A compelling subject line can entice people to open your email, while a boring or uninteresting subject line may cause it to be deleted or marked as spam.
  1. The Sender’s Name And Email Address: People are more likely to open emails from senders that they recognize and trust.
  1. The Email Content: The content of your email should be relevant, engaging, and provide value to your audience.
  1. The Frequency Of Emails: Sending too many emails can lead to fatigue and decreased engagement, while sending too few emails can cause you to be forgotten.
  1. The Email Format: The design and layout of your emails should be visually appealing and easy to read on both desktop and mobile devices.
  1. The Use Of Personalization: Personalized emails, such as those that include the recipient’s name or relevant information about their interests, can increase engagement.
  1. The Timing Of The Email: Sending emails at the right time can increase the chances of them being opened and clicked.

Tips For Improving Open And Click-Through Rates

As an insurance professional, I fully understand the importance and appeal of email marketing for insurance agencies. Here are some tips for improving the open and click-through rates of your insurance agency’s email marketing campaigns:

  1. Use A Clear And Concise Subject Line: The subject line should clearly convey the purpose of the email and be no more than 50 characters long.
  1. Use A Recognizable Sender Name And Email Address: Use your name or the name of your agency as the sender, and consider using a dedicated email address for your marketing campaigns.
  1. Personalize Your Emails: Use personalization tokens, such as the recipient’s name or location, to make the email feel more relevant to the individual.
  1. Segment Your Email List: Divide your email list into smaller groups based on factors such as location, interests, or past interactions with your agency. This will allow you to send more targeted and relevant emails to each group.
  1. Optimize Your Email Content: Make sure your email content is engaging, informative, and provides value to your audience. Use bullet points, numbered lists, and other formatting techniques to make the email easy to read.
  1. Test And Optimize Your Emails: Use A/B testing to compare the performance of different subject lines, email formats, or calls to action. This will help you determine what works best for your audience.
  1. Pay Attention To Email Frequency: Find the right balance between sending too many and too few emails. You can use analytics to track how often your audience engages with your emails and adjust your frequency accordingly.

Best Practices For Insurance Agency Email Marketing

As an independent insurance professional, I like to talk about the practices you can implement to improve your company. While the tips above will help you, there are steps and practices you can implement that will further improve your email marketing strategy. 

In addition to the tips mentioned above, here are some best practices to follow when conducting email marketing for your insurance agency:

  1. Get Permission: Make sure you have the recipient’s permission before adding them to your email list. This can be obtained through opt-in forms on your website or by asking people to sign up for your emails in person or over the phone.
  1. Provide An Easy Way To Unsubscribe: Include an unsubscribe link in all of your emails to allow recipients to easily opt out of receiving future emails.
  1. Follow Spam Laws: Familiarize yourself with laws such as the CAN-SPAM Act and make sure you are complying with them in your email marketing efforts.
  1. Use A Professional Email Service Provider: An email service provider (ESP) can help you manage your email list, create and send emails, and track the performance of your campaigns.
  1. Test Your Emails: Before sending your emails, make sure to test them on different devices and email clients to ensure that they are displayed correctly.


As an independent insurance professional, I know that email marketing is an important and effective marketing technique used by insurance companies. It helps agencies connect with their current and potential clients, build relationships, and promote services.

Be sure to follow the tips and practices outlined in this article to ensure the efficiency and effectiveness of your email marketing strategy. 

If you liked this blog check out our other insurance articles on: