Insurance leads are a resource that help provide potential customers who are interested in purchasing a policy. Two types are exclusive insurance leads and shared insurance leads. While each has its own benefit and risk, insurance agents must understand which works best for their business.
As a licensed insurance agent, I understand it can be confusing to know which insurance lead you should go with. In this article, I’ll talk about insurance leads, how they differ from each other, and what you should consider when choosing one.
| Key Takeaways |
|---|
| Exclusive insurance leads are leads that are sold to one insurance agent or company, while shared insurance leads are sold to multiple agents or companies. |
| Exclusive leads are typically more expensive than shared leads, but they can be more valuable because they give agents a better chance of closing a sale. |
| Shared leads can be a cost-effective way for new or smaller insurance agencies to generate leads, but they come with the risk of competition from other agents. |
| When buying shared leads, it’s important to choose a reputable lead provider and to have a plan for following up quickly and effectively with potential customers. |
| Some insurance agents prefer to generate their own leads through networking, referrals, and other means, rather than relying on shared or exclusive leads. |
Table of contents
What Are Exclusive Insurance Leads?
Exclusive insurance leads are a type of lead generation that allows an insurance sales representative to purchase the rights to a pre-qualified potential customer.
This means that the potential customer can only be contacted by the sales representative who purchased their information, not by any other sales representative.
Pro Tip: Exclusive insurance leads differ from shared insurance leads in that they are only available to one sales representative, whereas multiple sales representatives can purchase shared insurance leads.
Exclusive insurance leads are typically more expensive than shared insurance leads, but they can offer several benefits to insurance agents. Let’s explore these benefits in more detail.
Benefits Of Exclusive Insurance Leads
There are several benefits of using exclusive insurance leads in an insurance sales business such as time and overall ROI. I’ve used both exclusive and non-exclusive (shared leads) and have found that exclusive leads are the way to go!
- Time And Cost Savings: With exclusive insurance leads, sales representatives don’t have to spend as much time researching and qualifying potential customers. This can save a significant amount of time and resources, allowing sales representatives to focus on closing sales with qualified leads.
- Increased Chances Of Closing A Sale: Exclusive insurance leads are pre-qualified, meaning that the potential customer is interested in purchasing a policy. This can increase the chances of closing a sale, as the sales representative works with a more qualified lead.
Risks And Challenges Of Exclusive Insurance Leads
Exclusive insurance leads can be more expensive than shared insurance leads, and there is no guarantee that the lead will result in a sale. Additionally, if the lead is not interested in purchasing a policy, the sales representative will have wasted their time and resources. How many times I’ve had a “lead” on the phone who says they never filled out anything for a quote online and are confused about the whole process!
There are also a few risks and challenges to consider when using exclusive insurance leads:
- Research Lead Generation Companies: Work with a reputable lead generation company that provides high-quality leads.
- Determine A Budget: Determine a budget for purchasing exclusive insurance leads and to negotiate terms with the lead generation company.
- Follow Up With Potential Customers: Follow up with potential customers in a timely manner and provide value and personalized service to increase the chances of closing a sale.
Deciding on an exclusive lead can be risky. But I believe that by carefully weighing the risks and benefits to tailor individual strategies, insurance agents can effectively use exclusive insurance leads to grow their business.
In the next section, we’ll explore shared insurance leads and how they differ from exclusive insurance leads.
What Are Shared Insurance Leads?
Shared insurance leads are a type of lead generation that allows multiple insurance sales representatives to purchase the rights to a potential customer.
This means that a potential customer can be contacted by multiple sales representatives who have purchased their information.
Pro Tip: Shared insurance leads are typically less expensive than exclusive ones, but they also offer many benefits to insurance agents.
Benefits Of Shared Insurance Leads
Using shared insurance leads in an insurance sales business has several benefits. Although I prefer exclusive leads, there are merits of shared leads to consider!
- Cost Savings: Shared insurance leads are typically less expensive than exclusive insurance leads, which can be beneficial for insurance agents on a tight budget.
- Increased Volume Of Leads: With shared insurance leads, insurance agents have the opportunity to work with a larger volume of leads, which can increase their chances of making a sale.
Risks And Challenges Of Shared Insurance Leads
As in using any lead, I advise insurance agents to consider any risks and challenges. Let’s talk about those involved in shared insurance leads:
- Increased Competition: With shared insurance leads, there is increased competition with other sales representatives. This can make it more challenging to close a sale, as multiple sales representatives may contact the potential customer.
- Lower Chances Of Closing A Sale: Because shared insurance leads are not pre-qualified and are available to multiple sales representatives, the chances of closing a sale may be lower compared to exclusive insurance leads.
In the next section, we’ll compare the pros and cons of exclusive and shared insurance leads and provide factors to consider when deciding between the two.
Comparison Of Exclusive And Shared Insurance Leads
When comparing exclusive and shared insurance leads, not only is it important to consider the pros and cons of each, but also the specific needs and goals of your insurance business.
| Category | Shared Leads | Exclusive Leads |
|---|---|---|
| Definition | Multiple insurers receive the same lead | Only one insurer receives the lead |
| Cost Per Lead | Lower | Higher |
| Quality Of Lead | Lower | Higher |
| Competition | High | Low |
| Response Time | Shorter | Longer |
Pros Of Exclusive Insurance Leads:
- Pre-qualified leads
- Increased chances of closing a sale
- Time and cost savings
Cons Of Exclusive Insurance Leads:
- More expensive
- No guarantee of a sale
Pros Of Shared Insurance Leads:
- Less expensive
- Increased volume of leads
Cons Of Shared Insurance Leads:
- Increased competition
- Lower chances of closing a sale
Factors To Consider When Deciding Between Exclusive And Shared Insurance Leads:
- Budget: How much can you afford to spend on lead generation?
- Goals: What are your sales goals, and how many leads do you need to reach them?
- Lead quality: How important is it to you to work with pre-qualified leads?
Conclusion
In conclusion, whether to buy exclusive or shared insurance leads depends on an agent’s specific needs and goals. While exclusive leads can be more valuable, shared leads can be a cost-effective option for new or smaller agencies. Ultimately, it’s important to choose a reputable lead provider and have a plan for following up with potential customers to maximize the chances of closing a sale.
If you liked this blog check out our other insurance articles on:
