The Best Rental Property Insurance Companies

Investing in properties can be a lucrative source of income, but it also comes with risks and responsibilities. Insurance can protect you from events like natural disasters, accidents, and liability claims. Property, liability, and renters insurance are all options to protect your properties. 

Best Insurance For Investment Properties

As an independent insurance broker, I understand the appeal that property investment carries. It can definitely be a lucrative source of income, but it is important to purchase insurance to protect you and your properties from unexpected events.

There are a variety of insurance types to consider, such as property, liability, and renters insurance to protect yourself and your investments. In this article, we will discuss factors to consider when choosing insurance, the best options available, and offer tips and alternative options. Let’s get started! 

The Best Insurance Companies For Investment Properties

Landlord insurance is a special type of insurance that helps people who own investment properties, or rental properties, protect their assets. If you own a building or land that you rent out to others, landlord insurance is important because it covers your property in case something bad happens. This type of insurance is different from regular homeowners insurance because it’s only for people who own rental property.

When looking for landlord insurance, it’s important to find a company that offers a good price, is strong financially, and has customer service that’s easy to reach. The company should also have discounts and make it easy to get information about their policies and get a quote.

Here are the best companies to get quotes with first when looking for a great deal on insurance for your investment properties:

  1. Allstate: Allstate has a lot of options available that can protect your investment properties. They offer protection from property damage, loss of rental income, liability claims, interior vandalism, and theft of furnishing. They have a strong financial strength rating, and offer additional niche options to help protect your investment. 
  2. State Farm: State Farm offers a range of bundle insurance options to help protect your properties. They allow you to bundle multiple insurance types together which lowers your overall premium. They offer policies that cover coverage for workers’ compensation and commercial auto protection. State Farm is the best option if you are a full time landlord. 
  3. Travelers: Travelers is a well-known insurance company that offers great landlord insurance policies. They have a long history of providing quality coverage for rental property owners, and have a strong reputation for providing excellent customer service.

These are just a few of the best insurance options on the market to cover your investment properties. Other options include Farmers Insurance, Liberty Mutual, and USAA, to name a few. Each company offers their own policies with different coverage options. 

When ranking the best insurance companies for investment properties, we considered a variety of factors, including financial stability, customer satisfaction, coverage options, and pricing. 

We used a combination of data sources and methods, including ratings from independent agencies, customer review sites, and industry organizations, as well as our own analysis of coverage options and pricing.

Saving Money on Insurance with Bauple

Learn Tips to Save Money on Insurance!

Our newsletter is packed with helpful tips and resources to help you save money and get the most out of your coverage. Sign up now and join our community of savvy insurance consumers.

The form has been submitted successfully!
There has been some error while submitting the form. Please verify all form fields again.

Factors To Consider When Selecting Insurance For Investment Properties

When it comes to protecting your investment properties, insurance is a crucial component. It provides you with peace of mind and financial protection in case of unexpected events such as natural disasters, theft, or other damages.

Choosing the right insurance for your investment properties can be overwhelming with so many options available in the market. When selecting insurance for investment properties, it is important to consider the following factors:

  1. Financial Stability: It is essential to choose an insurance company that is financially stable, as this will ensure that they are able to pay out claims when necessary. You can check the financial stability of an insurance company by looking at ratings from independent agencies such as A.M. Best, Standard & Poor’s, and Moody’s.
  1. Customer Satisfaction: It is also important to choose an insurance company that has a good track record of customer satisfaction. Look for companies that have high ratings from customer review sites and industry organizations, as well as a history of handling claims fairly and efficiently.
  1. Coverage Options And Exclusions: It is important to carefully review the coverage options and exclusions of each insurance policy to ensure that you are getting the protection you need. Look for policies that offer a wide range of coverage options and have few exclusions, as this will help to protect you in the event of an unexpected event.
  1. Premiums And Cost-Saving Strategies: Insurance premiums can be a significant expense for landlords, particularly if you have multiple investment properties. It is important to consider the premiums and cost-saving strategies of each insurance policy to ensure that you are getting the best value for your money. Some strategies you may want to consider include raising deductibles, bundling policies, and taking advantage of discounts.

Tips For Finding The Best Insurance For Investment Properties

Investment properties require insurance coverage to protect against potential risks and losses and finding the best insurance for your investment properties can be a daunting task, with numerous options available in the market. To make the process easier, it is important to consider several key factors such as coverage options, policy limits, deductibles, cost, and customer service.

  1. Shop Around: Don’t be afraid to shop around and compare quotes from multiple insurance companies. This will help you to find the best coverage and pricing for your needs.
  1. Negotiate Premiums: If you have a good track record as a landlord and a history of maintaining your properties, you may be able to negotiate your premiums with an insurance company. Don’t be afraid to ask for discounts or negotiate a lower rate, as this can help to lower your overall costs.
  1. Work With An Independent Insurance Agent: An independent insurance agent can help you to shop around and compare quotes from multiple insurance companies. They can also offer advice and guidance on selecting the best policy for your needs.
  1. Consider Alternative Insurance Options: If you are having difficulty finding coverage through traditional channels, consider alternative insurance options, such as umbrella insurance or landlord insurance. These types of policies may have different coverage options and exclusions, so it is important to carefully review them to ensure that they meet your needs.

Alternative Insurance Options

As an insurance agent, I know that traditional insurance options aren’t for everyone! Maybe the above options don’t provide the protection you need, or just aren’t what you are looking for. If you are having difficulty finding insurance for your investment properties, there are several alternative options you may want to consider:

  • Umbrella Insurance: Umbrella insurance is a type of liability insurance that provides additional protection beyond the limits of your primary insurance policies. For landlords, umbrella insurance can provide additional protection against liability claims from tenants, such as personal injury or property damage.
  • Landlord Insurance: Landlord insurance is a type of property insurance specifically designed for landlords. It typically covers the building and contents of an investment property, as well as liability protection for landlords. Landlord insurance can be a good option for landlords who own multiple properties or have high-value properties.
  • Business Insurance: If you own a rental business, you may want to consider business insurance, which can provide coverage for your business assets, including your investment properties. Business insurance can also provide liability protection in the event of a claim related to your rental business.


As an insurance agent, I know that investing in property can be a lucrative source of income, so it is important to make sure your properties are protected in the event of unexpected events. There are a lot of insurance options that can help protect you and your property.

Be sure to carefully consider the factors outlined in this article to make sure you are choosing a plan that works for you. If you have difficulty finding coverage, or standard coverage simply isn’t what you need, consider the alternative insurance options provided.